Home

Advertisement

Previous Entry | Next Entry

A pictures worth 1000 words

  • May. 1st, 2009 at 6:41 AM
puppy pacifier
A recent posting in the WebOS forums showed side by side the features from Palm Pre vs the same features in the iphone. Its a matter of opinion still Im sure however I have to say, the Palm Pre looks prettier and from what I know so far will function just as good as the iPhone. Take a look and feel free to give your thoughts.

http://www.desmondsdoghouse.com/prevsiphone.html

Comments

( 5 comments — Leave a comment )
[info]chetchez wrote:
May. 1st, 2009 05:06 pm (UTC)
Some problems with your comparison:

First the screen:
Palm Pre: 3.1" touchscreen with 480x320 resolution.
Apple iPhone: 3.5" touchscreen with 480x320 resolution.

The iPhone has a larger screen, although they both have the same resolution but the images you posted show the iPhone images smaller than the Pre. This easily invalidates any comparisons.

Screen captures:
Images like the iPhone Dialer and Full Page Web Browsing aren't screen captures from the device and are taken with an external camera. This leads to washed out images not suitable for comparison.

Day/Week View:
The pre shows a calendar populated with dates, the iPhone calendar has no dates posted. Comparing Apples to Oranges, figuratively and (somewhat) literally.
[info]champsf wrote:
May. 1st, 2009 05:41 pm (UTC)
I will agree the screen is a little bigger however lets keep in mind that your fingers on the Pre will not be occupying that .4 inch difference since the gesture area starts below the screen. That gives you complete view of your screen without interuption. I will say, the screen shots and photos do make the iphone look smaller but I was also comparing which one looks nicer graphically and I still have to say I think the Pre is a bit more "clean" looking.

Although I do agree that the iphone may not have anything on the calendar, I do like from the demo of the Pre's calendar, the accordian style to filter out unused time which can be expanded by touching the fold. Definitely a great touch.

The web browser is to be determined as the pictures do not do either one justice.

Im still pro Pre and think think it will prove to be better when released but we'll never know till its out.
[info]brothercarl wrote:
May. 1st, 2009 07:23 pm (UTC)
While it may not be a good comparison of which has a better quality hardware screen, or which size of screen is easier to work with, the comparison is still valid for looking at things like how the icon artwork is done, the layout of screen elements, and the fact that the Mail application allows you to view all inboxes at once! (Something that the iPhone woefully lacks, which is surprising since Mail.app is awesome in the way it does that. Maybe 3.0 will fix that.) And as he said, it is mostly a matter of taste with respect to layout and artwork.

Personally I love the way the Pre WebOS looks and is reported to function. As with the iPhone before it came out, only hands-on testing will say how good it really is or isn't. But based on what I have seen, I want, want, want a Pre as bad as [info]champsf does (I think).
[info]champsf wrote:
May. 6th, 2009 02:37 pm (UTC)
Palm Pre in Canada 2nd half of 2009
[info]brothercarl wrote:
May. 6th, 2009 02:50 pm (UTC)
Re: Palm Pre in Canada 2nd half of 2009
Hey, thanks for letting me know! I hadn't seen that yet. While I am definitely excited about confirmation of a time frame, I am slightly disappointed about the carrier. I was hoping for Telus as that is who my hubby just signed up with. Oh well, haha.
( 5 comments — Leave a comment )